Regulating the Electric Industry

Henry Thompson

 

The first step in regulating the US electric industry occurred during the 1930s when the large producers lobbied with state governments to make themselves franchise monopolies based on economies of scale. The result was elimination of competing firms in the industry. In return, the state governments received reliable tax revenue effectively sharing the monopoly profit. Abundant energy resources have kept the price of electricity low.

The main cost of electricity is fuel. Coal remains the main fuel. Natural gas burns cleaner and has become more available. Hydroelectricity is reliable but limited and unable to expand given environmental concerns over more dams. Nuclear generation will become more important over the coming decades. Alternative energy sources can eventually provide a good share of the electricity as technology improves.

Interstate retail competition allows customers to choose suppliers across state lines. Customers in high priced states such as California, New York, and Florida want to buy from low priced exporting states such as West Virginia, Idaho, and Alabama. Interstate retail competition will raise prices in the exporting states.

The best policy to keep the price of electricity low is to avoid taxes and subsidies. Consumers facing higher prices for electricity will economize. The price of electricity ultimately depends on investment by the industry.